The John Nicholls Medal (formerly the Robert Reynolds Trophy from 1934-2003) is an Australian rules football award given to the player(s) adjudged Best and Fairest for the Carlton Football Club for the season.
John Nicholls was a champion ruckman who won the award five times from 1959 to 1967.
Recipients:
| Best and Fairest awards in the Australian Football League |
| Adelaide Crows - Malcolm Blight Medal | Brisbane Lions - Merrett-Murray Medal | Carlton - John Nicholls Medal | Collingwood - Copeland Trophy Essendon - Crichton Medal | Fremantle - Doig Medal | Geelong - Carji Greeves Medal | Hawthorn - Peter Crimmins Medal Melbourne - Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Medal| North Melbourne - Syd Barker Medal | Port Adelaide - John Cahill Medal | Richmond - Jack Dyer Medal St Kilda - Trevor Barker Award | Sydney Swans - Bob Skilton Medal | West Coast Eagles - Club Champion Award | Western Bulldogs - Charles Sutton Medal Defunct: Fitzroy - Mitchell Medal |